Wednesday, November 25, 2015

The Selfish Gene and The Fertile Meme

Chromosomes
I just finished reading Richard Dawkins's famous book, The Selfish Gene, and my mind is reeling. This is no cold, wonderless mechanistic description of life, but a  collection of some of the most astonishing stories known to humankind. Truth (in the form of science), as has many times been noted, is stranger than fiction. One of the more mind-expanding ideas Dawkins explores in this book is the question of why, in the first place, replicators (genes) have come to cluster into bodies (survival machines) at all. Why did they not simply float in the primordial soup and fend for themselves in the great choreography of survival-replication? In an attempt to answer this basic question with which he begins and ends the book, "Why are People?", Dawkins also explores the question of "What are People," i.e., to what extent does it even make sense to see ourselves as discrete complete separate organisms. A body (plant, animal, human) is, in Dawkin's view, basically a vehicle for the many genes which cooperatively cluster together in their own interest (which consists in making it out of the body on the bottleneck of egg or sperm so that they can each reproduce themselves). The body, which thinks of itself as a solid entity of sorts, is made up of many different organisms which cluster together, each only interested in the body's health and well being insofar as it enables reproduction. He even suggests that what is now a complete system of a body may at one time have been a parasite (or many parasites) interacting for mutual benefit within the survival machine. Parasite and host unite over time and become one. Viruses, apparently, are rogue chromosomes splitting off from inside bodies and traveling on coughs and sneezes to infest other bodies and hopefully make a home and nest therein. A stranger's cough is a gene's attempt to invade your body and eventually become one with your other genes, your phenotype. The world around us, not just other bodies, is also part of what Dawkins calls the extended phenotype. Not only the natural essences of bodies, like snail shells or hair, but also things that our bodies make, like beaver dams and, possibly, though he doesn't say this, art. There is, in a sense, no separation between body and body, body and world, except at the individual cellular level. Every living replicator is interacting with other replicators and with the changing environment in really complex ways to respond to and create ideal situations, or Evolutionary Stable Strategy (ESS), for generation. That the gene is selfish, i.e, wants its own reproduction above all else, need not mean that its vehicle is selfish, especially when it comes to humans who have, Dawkins notes, the ability of conscious foresight and of overruling the interests of the gene and natural selection (consider both birth control and the welfare state, the latter ensuring that the gene for having more children than can be cared for is unnaturally allowed to survive and proliferate).  While it is distinctly not natural and has, he notes, never been done, there is no reason why humans could not choose to create an entirely altruistic society. The meme, a word coined by Dawkins, is the replicator that takes over the gene's role when it comes to society and culture. It too is a replicator and it too ensures its survival unconsciously through proliferation in survival machines which themselves do not replicate but only carry genes and memes. Are memes the same as social constructs? What does it take for a meme to survive? According to Dawkins, the proliferating meme needs to have the same qualities that a proliferating gene has: longevity, fecundity, copying fidelity (they don't get changed too much over time). Some memes, like celibacy or self-sacrifice for one's country, work against the interest of genes. Some, like blind faith, or God, seem to provide no apparent biological advantage (though some of Dawkins's colleagues disagree with him on this). The meme need not be in harmony with natural facts, but it probably does serve some human need (Dawkins gives the example of the belief in afterlife, which comes naturally out of a human fear of death and the unknown). The ones that catch on, that are fecund, long-lasting, and have copying fidelity, do so for a combination of reasons including human psychology, the particular social and natural environment at the time, the other competing memes in the meme pool. Genes too interact with their environments in the attempt to reduplicate and survive (which reminds us of the nature/nurture debate), and, as such, we can see that while what is genetic is extremely influential upon who we are, the benefits or drawbacks of particular gene-characteristics depend to a large degree on the particular social contexts that the survival machines housing the genes live in. We (or shall I say, the individual genes which have clustered inside of and built their vehicles, which we call our bodies and conscious minds) have come a long way from the primordial soup. Our ideas about the world, and the meanings we ascribe to it, are determined by many different factors, biological, social, environmental, by chance. And just how the interaction functions (between what is determined and what is determinable, between what we are and what we could be, between mechanistic pre-programming and choice and creation and possibility) is one of the most exciting unanswered questions of life.

Tuesday, September 29, 2015

Reality, Evidence, Language, Social Construction, Darwin

I have been thinking and reading lately a good deal about the social construct of the social construct and trying to parse out what of our perceived reality is more or less repeatable, verifiable, universally experienced, and what is more or less constructed by individual and group abstraction, personal or social narratives, conscious or unconscious leaving out or foregrounding. The ubiquitous phrase, "that's just a social construct" has become a sort of a joke around the house as we tell someone who has stubbed her toe or who has a headache or who thinks she is in love or who believes she has succeeded that her perception is little more than a delusion brought on by her own or more probably her society's way of framing and describing reality. The assumption is that her pain, her pleasure, her ideas of success could just as easily be different feelings or be inspired by utterly different causes if only....The assumption is that our ways of looking at the world are randomly constructed (that they have been randomly constructed at some time in the past by some people who constructed them for no particular reasons or perhaps in order to benefit themselves and make others suffer). This concept is, of course, grounded in the philosophical realization that it is impossible to experience, see, know " the thing in itself". We see only phenomena and not realities, and our seeing is determined by filters or structures in our brains that direct the ways in which we see. This realization has been transformed, however, to mean that what we see is necessarily either wrong or extremely different from what is, an assumption that was not present in Kant's analysis. The Modernist appropriation of Kant also exaggerated the differences between what one brain and another is likely to see. While Kant did note that each person sees a different shade of red, he did not suggest that we each see entirely different colors, or that colors themselves did not exist. While our seeing is determined by all sorts of things, both biological and experiential, there is no reason to assume that two human brains will necessarily see something radically differently all the time.
     Nietzsche, inaugurating the "linguistic turn," made us aware of the way language conceptualizes reality by creating names or descriptions of things (terms) that leave out as much as they contain. Words are inexact figures and metaphors, inaccurate and incommensurate attempts to describe reality. We group similar things that nevertheless exhibit many differences under categories; and this process induces a sort of simplification of seeing. We come to see dogs, trees, men, women, instead of individual creatures and entities. This eventually leads us to create concepts and reifications, such as love, good, bad, noble, moral, money, which are more and more removed from physical reality and experience. While many theorists after Nietzsche came to see this use of language as a treacherous crime committed by language upon reality, he tended to see it in a more creatively joyous light: just as long as we do not come to be the slaves of ossified constructs and concepts, just as long as the  "creative subject" continues to make new terms, new words, new metaphors, new figures to describe a changing reality from his own shifting perspective, just as long as individuals stoke the flame of a living language, language can be a prod and a stimulus to new seeing.
     Social construction theory has tried to moralistically discredit this joyous aesthetic and existential world- and word-making  activity and replaced it with an imperative to strip every word and every concept of its given meaning by calling all designations and conceptualizations into question. This leaves us with strictly nothing but experience itself, unsung, unquestioned, unnamed. They would discredit myth, historic narrative, fairy tales, religious legends, songs, poems, paintings, totems, talismans as random and treacherous social constructions. They would have us scoff at any product of the human imagination as a product with some abstract non-human author, as something necessarily imposed upon from some force that would have to be extra-terrestrial, not ouselves, not natural. They would insist that a human is not capable of experiencing his or her reality without being blind-sided by the already constructed way of seeing determined in his or her society. Of course our visions and perspectives are colored by our social context and these visions do vary from one culture to another, often extremely; but these variations do not come randomly out of nowhere. The variations between cultures must be the product of many different influences, from climate to landscape to the requirement for survival of a particular place and a particular people. Originary group social experiences are passed down from generation to generation, and are altered or not over time. Certainly old customs can be kept longer than necessary and humans on the whole may act according to originary evolutionary necessities that are no longer useful and even sometimes harmful in our current context. But these ways of seeing and ways of acting are not random. In other words, while there certainly are many social constructs, there is no such thing as "just" a social construct (a phrase that suggests that the construct has appeared out of nowhere and that it has no validity whatsoever). Social constructs, including language, are the product of human interaction with nature, the physical world, social groups, experience. They must always be questioned and often must be challenged, and each creative subject has the power and responsibility to create new ones which must interact with those created by others. Influence, interaction, discourse, criticism, the scientific method, testing of assumptions, positing of hypotheses and theories, gathering of facts and evidence to support the hypotheses and theories, foregrounding certain facts over others, selecting out and focusing on one or another aspect, evaluating based on differing values and differing relative needs of the moment. While many things may be true and verifiable, everything is not. Anything does not go, though many things might.
    I have been reading a biography of Darwin (The Survival of Charles Darwin by Ronald Clark) and thinking about these questions within the context of evolution. Is evolution a social consruct? No better than the one it replaced? Darwin's critics accused him of gathering data to support his hypothesis, as if such a process was manipulative and dishonest. Clark writes:  "Darwin himself had written years earlier in the third of his 'Species' notebooks: 'The line of argument often pursued throughout my theory is to establish a point as a probability by induction & to apply it as hypotheses to other points & see whether it will solve them.' And after publication of The Origin, he commented: 'How odd it is that anyone should not see that all observation must be for or against some view if it is to be of any service!'"(140). In the twenty years of gathering and testing evidence from the natural world leading up to his writing of The Origin of Species, Darwin actually worked from observation toward hypothesis in a remarkably innocent way, not expecting to find (to borrow Nietzsche's wonderful image in "On Truth and Lying in a Supramoral Sense") the truth he had himself hidden behind a bush. He actually discovered data that disproved the socially constructed truth of his society, proving that individuals are not such dupes as social construction theory makes us out to be. We are capable of overturning the constructions created by our predecessors, challenging, criticizing, or revising the constructs and narratives of other humans throughout time and across space, following errors to new truths or old truths to new errors. We can continue to do this, or we can decide, with the social constructionist theorists and their deconstructionist progeny that no way in which anyone has ever described the world, no poem, no theory, no evaluation or re-evaluation of values is reality-relevant (except of course the social construction of social construction theory or deconstructionist skepticism), that language is a crime against nature, and the history of ideas and the idealistic pursuit of education is an Enlightenment plot to impose random (or are they actually based on the preferences of the people in power, which then, would actually be natural and thus not a construction?) ideas of good and bad on a beknighted populace? We can just do away with our libraries and our picture galleries, our approximate meanings and our attempts to understand what cannot ever be completely mastered, our mythologies and our delightful misprisions, and smugly, certainly, moralistically and accurately, resort to grunting and sneezing. No misleading words, no oppressive influences, no images to teach us that one thing or person is more beautiful or more valuable than another, no theories, no ideas at all, only an honest gaping silent void.

    

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Excerpt from "Portals: Cabinets of Curiosity, Collections, Reliquaries, Colonialism"


This essay won the Jeffrey E. Smith Editor's Prize for Non-Fiction from The Missouri Review and will be published in its entirety in Spring, 2015.


Portals:
Cabinets of Curiosity, Collections, Reliquaries, Colonialism, and the Complexity of Human Life
 
le souvenir de ces maisons s’est deposé dans mon
            sang
            et court aux points cardinaux de mon corps
            Il leva le bras. Une petite troupe de chevaliers
            errants
            et d’assassins encercla le bourg comme une barrique
            cerclée de fer
            -Francine Y. Prevost
At the Maison Gai Saber, where I am trying to collect my thoughts about Schatzkammer, reliquaries, ornament, crime, and civilization and its discontents, all the matter has history: all of the earth, all the rocks, going back to the Paleolithic age, and the land, worked and harvested for centuries, the grape vines, the fig trees (which yield montagnes de figes), the old stone houses with cellars and attics. Yesterday I worked in the garden with Francine, my hostess at this special artists’ residency in the Loire valley of France, removing ten years of ground cover and vines from an area outside the pressoire (a house built by Francine’s father, a master carpenter, which is so called because of a beautiful gigantic old wooden cask-press for grapes sitting on its porch). While we worked we uncovered wild garlic and snails and small new prodding flowers. Every material thing here is bound or connected to the past via blood lines, via deep ruts in the fields, etchings on the surface of earth’s memory, that reach deep down under the soil to places we cannot see, but surely feel.  Francine herself was born here, in this house, and her family goes back for generations. Thus the earth we were working was worked by her forefathers and foremothers, over and over again, hands like her hands in the same moist, rich dirt.  In the Maison library (where other vines go back to other roots, bifurcating out over vast geographic areas and times to ancient Greece, medieval France, 20th Century German history and philosophy, Japanese courtly poetry, Arabian-Andalusian melodies), I picked up Civilization and Its Discontents, wherein Freud writes about the way our childhood selves are carried within our grown bodies, just as the ancient foundations of old cities may still somehow exist beneath the new structure.  I also rediscovered Marcel Mauss’s wonderful book, The Gift, about ancient and primitive gift exchange, called the potlatch in some traditions, and about the ‘mana’ of objects, and a world wherein objects are not reduced to commodities bought and sold between strangers without any emotional, social, or spiritual bonds. The mana that lives in an object once owned by someone is passed on to the recipient. And as it is farther passed on, its power and value increases. This reminded me of the sense we have of the powers inherent in old things, and old places, and in the late offspring of old families, with their mingled lines of influence and geography, of ethnicities and languages. The tragedy is that these braids of meaning can be cut off, diminished, denigrated when the objects, persons, and places they form are used and abused in merely mercenary ways.  When an object, a place, or a person is cut off from the circulating energy of community, history, nature, and the life blood of heritage and exchange, it becomes sterile and loses its mana. Severed from the forces that made it, the craftsperson who formed it, the animal and natural materials of which it was constructed, a relic becomes a mere thing, with no meaning.   
A person, too, can become an object, when alienated from her surroundings, her history, and her roots, although occasional spiritual and physical journeys  away from home are instructive and refreshing; and there seem to be some people—travelers and expatriates—who find their homes or perhaps their anti-selves in constant transition or in far-off lands. But even these wanderers are tracing lines of contact, walking paths and touching artifacts which seem somehow to be calling to them. Even they are treasuring places and the objects and people who have been either born or created there or which have arrived there via circuitous, surprising routes—routes which are stories and heritages in themselves. And a home or a land is robbed of its ancient magic insofar as its ancient trees, ancient houses, ancient foundations, ancient tales, myths, and songs are cut down and forgotten. These sorts of considerations compel us to reconsider certain modern-day prejudices against materiality and to work to rediscover old ways to understand why many of us continue to love objects no matter how implicated they may be in things we ostensibly don’t love.
It is so difficult to imagine a time when humans were not driven by merely economic ends (“Getting and spending, we lay waste our powers” as Wordsworth had it). But the roots of such a time are still traceable, and we may uncover them, reanimate them, and cultivate them today if we choose. But in another, more popular book on the gift, by Lewis Hyde, it is suggested that, since gift exchange is a complex and fraught relationship, often dangerous and messy, some modern people may actually prefer the commodification of objects and life because it gives them a sense of freedom from the group, from the commonality, the family, the tribe. Thus, the “free society” may be not so much about political freedoms as about the freedom of individual determination, the freedom to leave the group and fend for one’s self, the sense of anonymity and of not being beholden to anyone of capitalist commodity exchange.  This explains why one may prefer a sterile cold hotel to the awkwardness of staying in a warm home with strangers, who may become friends.  While cleaning up after dinner, Francine and I agree that this sort of anonymity does have its charms too, for a poet or artist who escapes for a while from everyone she knows to live in a foreign city, unwatched, unbound.  And of course in our modern world, we often stray very far from our homes and our people, abandoning native languages, customs, and the obligations of kinship that go along with them. There are, of course, often good reasons why a person would want to be cut off from his family or his national heritage and culture, but such a separation can probably only be achieved by a truncating and repression of parts of ourselves, parts that it might be better to bring up to the surface in all their messy material complexity. At best, we adopt new families, learn new languages, invent new customs, putting down new roots, and creating and collecting new keepsakes; and at worst, we float amid shallow connections without identity, without meaningful possessions or mementos to hold us down, without a place to call home, without attachments.

Monday, August 20, 2012

Thoreau's notes in his Bhagavad Gita

Thoreau was given a "royal gift" by his friend Chalmondely of 44 volumes, principally of translations of sacred texts of the Vedic philosophy of India. The books arrived on November 30th, 1855, and Thoreau records his first night sleeping beside them, as they sat on a shelf he had made expressly for them: “After overhauling my treasures…I placed them in the case which I had prepared and went late to bed dreaming of what had happened. Indeed it was exactly like the realization of some dreams which I have had; but when I woke in the morning I was not convinced that it was a reality until I peeped out and saw their bright backs”.  David Wood, who narrates this event  in The Observant Eye ( 70), notes that Thoreau's reading of these books, marked by his notations and underlinings, is a record of a link of "two great traditions in human thought, the idealist tradition of Greek philosophy and the Vedic idealist tradition of India...". Wood, whose book on Thoreau's fascination with material culture, tells us that Thoreau marked the following particular passage in the Bhagavad Gita. In this way, Wood is himself tracing the spiritual events of Thoreau's life through the material markings inscribed in the physical world: "There is no existence for what does exist, nor is there any non-existence for what exists. But even of both of these, those who discern the truth perceive the true end"(qtd. Wood, 73).

What is a Book? (An Elegy in Progress)


What is a book? A record, a new thing, a reflection, its own shining, a synthesis of all that there already was or is into  something never before existing? A novel arrangement of ideas and images in new proportions, it needs to exist in space and to take its place next to all the already existent objects of the world. Not to be simply erased or deleted, but firmly present in weight and dimension, density, thickness, and height. If you want to make a book go away, you have to burn it, and thereby consider what it is you are trying to suppress.

In-scription, In-spiration. It must in-teract with the physical, with carving, with breath, it must push up against what already is, against a resistance of the real. Lacking weight, it lacks substance, lacks power, lacks heft, lacks reality. If imagination is to gain credence, have purchase over the status quo, it must be given body, in art, in the author-ity of the book bound with in-tention (tension too) and care. It exists in the in between realm between that which already is and that which is mere fancy or thought. It is not frozen or fixed like reality as a given event, choice, object or mode of life, but is still freely intermediary as possibility, as embodied experiment, an offering…as one book among many, next to other books, a midrash, conversation, over ages, timelessly present. 

What is a book? A considered arrangement of words and ideas and images, a statement or explanation of passionate concerns, it is bound on both sides, necessitating some choice, closure, temporary decision and selecting out, It is not the whole world, though it may offer itself as microcosm, as metaphor for the whole world. It is a contribution to the larger cosmos, a piece of it, one voice in a choir. It is observer and witness and also evidence and artifact; it is a record of what happened and of what did not, of what is and what could be, a polemic, an elegy, a wish and a regret. What is a book? A moment and a time traveler, a reflection of the present and a conversation reaching backward over time and forward into the future, speaking with the long dead and booming forth so that the now living can speak with those who have not yet been born,

There are particular volumes we love, the Vie de Boheme, passed around and signed, as each one reads it he or she becomes a member of the Bohemian club, the favorite foxed Swift, the Hafiz with the golden marbleized silk, the crimson leather Looking Glass, purchased in Bath, the....And together they make up a rainbow, their variegated spines lining the walls, the cocoons of our  studies that are like another layer of mind around our skulls, where the ideas and fancies can circulate, where we might even open up a volume to refresh our memories as we reach in the repositories of the mind itself when grasping after a word, a passage, a line that haunts us. And find a pressed flower, a lover’s beribboned lock, a note slipped in by former readers, by unknown friends who stopped some afternoon, like us, upon a special passage in the same book, and reflected on its import as the rain poured down outside, or sun, or hail, or canon fire. A book may have traveled far in time and space, and seen many things it does not tell straight out, though tell it might, were we to read between its lines, and trace the signs on spine and endpapers, in foxings, spills, folds, and inset slips of paper, leaves, and other tokens of lives once lived. Responses to the words of the book itself, or the book's ideas mixed with the impressions of the outside world, fleeting and changing, perchance, either scribbled in margins or inserted on thin onion skin between the pages, conversations with the ages, and curious bookmarks from book stores long gone under…

(The smell of a book, some say,  like the smell of a woman…or the musky smell of a man:  one loves it if one loves the man or woman, and whosoever does not love women and men and books, well...)

The ones put away in annexes because they were for special tastes only…yet when the exotic seeker finds them he feels himself as lucky as any treasure hunter, though decades had gone by before anyone dreamed of wanting her. She waits, in silence, in a dark humble room for decades, her name forgotten but for a mention in some other obscure tome, and might one day, be important to some one.


To see the collected libraries of beloved long dead authors, the books they read and gazed at from their chairs, thumbed and pored over, perused and fell asleep beside or stayed awake to devour, read from to a lover or a daughter, fervently sighed or fulminated over, to touch the passages where they were first discovered, in original margins and on the page—atop, below, betwixt one page and the next—can mean so much…what word is underlined, what drop of sweat atop what page, what well-worn even dog-eared much returned to creased passage? Will there even be libraries like these in the future, or will the writers and readers of today leave no trace at all of their obsessions, their particular passions, even their guilty pleasures, of the concatenation of strange taste next to more catholic, of ancient next to contemporary, of pulp alongside sacred, of scientific next to fantastical, or poetical alongside logical treatise…no trace at all of what, if anything, they cared enough about to own, to arrange, to carry, to move in heavy boxes from house to house, nor what of all the wit and wisdom of the world was granted a place in the limited space of their mortal book shelves. Oh book shelves! And book ends, in forms as various as peacock tails and locomotives, sphinxes and cities. Are you to be artifacts of the past, now used only to hold unspeakably de-spirited objects, and maybe in time not even a ghostly still photograph staring back at us from the depths of the ages.

A book will show its age and the age of what was written in it. Its binding faded and pages foxed and worn, its weathered pages tell a history. If it survived a fire, say, or was salvaged, water-logged,  from a flood, swollen and heroic, its pages like the waves themselves, no virgin parchments more, but experienced travelers, a testament to salty, briny life, and death and grit. It carries more than just its content, its body itself is encrusted with life, with barnacles and breath, signs of contact with the past and signs to carry into the future, as messages of what we loved and of what we thought and dreamed.

A book has a place of origin, a home and history, bound in the materials of its birthplace, of Spanish leather or Chinese silk, in Irish linen or American flax, in Japanese rice paper, or Indian hemp, its type and design teeming with tell-tale signs, its orthography shifting from decade to decade, with emphasis in black letter or in subtle san serif, hand-colored or with gilded spine, embossed and crammed with delicate serigraph portraits and etched maps and charts that fold out and expand the very world. 

It has a place and time of death, when the spine is so cracked it falls off of itself and reveals the interior organs of the book, what old papers were used to glue on the spine, and what string used to stitch. When the book begins to die we see how it was born, and marvel at the sturdy but delicate art that bound the separate ventricles, and married the cover boards to the rest, with marbleized or silken end papers, we see its hopeful beginning, as it was christened with colophon and edition, and sent out into the world; and though its title might now be barely visible, rubbed off by many loving fingers, and its leaves are close to crumbling, perused over centuries by our fellows, we can take it one more time up to our noses and inhale its smell of life and moldering decay, and in this bouquet we recognize our own fate, and listen carefully to the whisperings of this old sage, as the pages crumble in our hands. Books tied up with string, their brittle leather covers crumbling, the pages falling out like loose teeth and the thin white hair of sages, still whispering wisdom, but so low we must lean in close to hear, before they turn entirely to dust and the secrets are lost for ever. There is always that last moment when we know that to turn the page may be to consign it to oblivion; yet we hope that it may speak to us one last time, so we dare, and touch, and hasten thereby the inevitable force of time. But that, my mortal friends, is life. And a well-made book, though it crumbles to dust, lasts a good deal longer than most of us.

Friday, February 3, 2012

Scrolls

"The continuous length of the roll of script, the 'locomotion' implicit in its format, the unrolling of it (which still echoes in the term 'volume' now applied to another referent), raised the possibility of creating laterally open pictorial compositions. The codex, with its sequence of relatively small, separate leaves, requires lateral enclosure of pictorial space, identifying it with the finite space of the page of the book"(Otto Pächt, The Illuminated Book in the Middle Ages, 25-26).